A proposal to let Virginia voters self-impose photo ID rules for their own ballot failed in the state Senate Tuesday along with every other Republican effort to reinstate mandatory photo ID in state elections.

In a meeting Tuesday afternoon, the nine Democrats on the Senate Privileges and Elections Committee repeatedly overruled six Republicans to kill the first batch of GOP-sponsored voting bills coming over from the House of Delegates.

In addition to blocking several photo ID bills, the committee defeated efforts to cut the early voting window from 45 days to 14 days, repeal the same-day voter registration system set to be implemented this year and ban absentee drop boxes.

As a result of those votes, all bills to bring back photo ID, a policy priority for Gov. Glenn Youngkin, are dead for the year. Though most Virginia voters still show a photo ID before casting their ballot, Democrats changed the law in 2020 to allow voters without ID to sign a form affirming their identity.

That includes the unconventional approach suggested by Del. Amanda Batten, R-James City, who said she filed her bill creating an opt-in photo ID system in response to an elderly constituent concerned about identity theft who “wanted to ensure that every time they were asked to purchase anything or vote that they would have to show a photo ID.”

After several Republicans speakers said they had heard stories of people going to vote and finding out someone else had voted in their name, incredulous Democrats pressed for specifics and asked why there had been no formal complaints backed by evidence.

“Are those cases being prosecuted by anybody? If they’re not, why not? And why don’t we read about them in the newspaper?” asked Sen. Creigh Deeds, D-Bath.

Clara Belle Wheeler, a former Republican member of the State Board of Elections, suggested it was too difficult to pursue fraud claims “because there’s no one to prosecute.” Upon further questioning, Wheeler said she could not provide the names of anyone who had claimed to have their ballot stolen.

(Editor’s Note: This article was published with permission by the Virginia Mercury.)