by Virginia Mercury Staff

ACLU launches investigation into possible abuses of civil rights across campuses

Following the violent police response and mass arrests of students, staff, and faculty protestors on multiple Virginia campuses this spring amid the flaring Israel-Hamas war, the ACLU of Virginia has launched an investigation into potential abuses of civil rights and liberties.

The organization submitted Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests to several universities across the commonwealth, seeking information on selective enforcement and viewpoint discrimination, the use of force by campus and state police, and the due process afforded to students and university employees subjected to disciplinary actions.

However, the responses to these FOIA requests have been largely unsatisfactory, the ACLU said in a statement. The universities — which include Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU), Virginia Tech, the University of Virginia (UVA), and the University of Mary Washington (UMW) — cited exemptions that allowed them to withhold information or indicated they would provide details only for exorbitant fees.

Mary Bauer, executive director of the ACLU of Virginia, expressed disappointment at the lack of transparency.

“Universities are charged with creating environments that encourage students to exercise their First Amendment rights,” Bauer said. “After deploying state police and imposing questionable disciplinary charges against student demonstrators this spring, university leaders should be more forthcoming about their decision-making processes and how they will enforce the new policies passed over the summer.”

Bauer emphasized that Virginians, who fund public universities with their tax dollars, deserve clarity on how their civil rights and liberties are being protected. “Transparency is essential — without exception, exemption, or hefty fees.”

Media pushes for courtroom access in Otieno case

Powhatan Circuit Court Judge Joseph M. Teefey initially barred reporters from the courtroom during jury selection for the trial concerning Irvo Otieno’s death, but relented after requests from reporters with the Richmond Free Press and the Richmond Times-Dispatch, the latter publication reported earlier this week. 

The trial, which opened Monday, involves Wavie Jones, a former Central State Hospital employee charged with involuntary manslaughter in Otieno’s March 2023 death.

Otieno, who died while handcuffed and restrained, was ruled to have died from asphyxiation by a medical examiner. However, Jones’ defense argues Otieno died of a “sudden cardiac event” due to an enlarged heart, and that Jones positioned Otieno on his side to avoid restricting his breathing. Prosecutors counter that Jones used excessive force and disobeyed orders not to get involved.

Otieno’s death, captured on hospital security footage, gained national attention, with the video being scrutinized in court. Witnesses had conflicting memories about Otieno’s position during the restraint, and hospital policies against prone restraints were introduced as evidence.

Jones is the only remaining hospital employee facing charges after some were dropped against others. The trial has evoked themes of civil rights and police reform, with several potential jurors removed for their views on police use of force. Otieno’s family attended the trial, with his mother, Caroline Ouko, reacting emotionally during discussions of graphic evidence.

(Virginia Mercury is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Virginia Mercury maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Samantha Willis for questions: info@virginiamercury.com. Follow Virginia Mercury on Facebook and X.)